Loading Light

Best Pizza Restaurant In
Carmel, IN

Mellow Mushroom - Carmel, IN

Mellow Mushroom makes the best pizza in Carmel, Indiana. Our unique restaurant is located in Merchants Square off East 116th Street. Mellow is a favorite among locals from Carmel, Fishers, Zionsville, and the surrounding areas. Craving pizza? Maybe it’s time to try something a little more unique. We’re known for our homemade crust and stone-baked pizzas with bold combinations. And if we can make pizza special, just imagine what we can do with a munchie, salad, calzone, or even a burger. Are you hungry yet? Definitely. Take your pick from our selection of 16 draft beers including local breweries like Bell’s, Bier Works, and SunKing. And because we are inclusive of everyone’s needs, many of our pizzas can be made gluten-free or vegan.

Store Information

Generic Mellow Mushroom landing page banner store blue background since 1974
Monday - Sunday
Happy Hour
All Day Everyday
Pint Specials

2340 E 116th St, Carmel, IN, 46032

Curbside Pickup
When you arrive to pick up your order, please pull to the front of the restaurant and call 317-846-2400. Let our team know your name, where you are parked and the make and model of your car. A Mellow team member will deliver your order to your car.
To-go orders
Pick up TO GO orders at the cash register
Social Media

Reserve a Room

Throwing a party for a crowd? Reserve the best seat in the house. Our classic VW Bus has been converted to a booth and is perfect for birthday celebrations or team events.
VW Bus: 20 Guests
Reservation Fee: No reservation charge
Reserve: Click the button below to reserve or call 317-846-2400

Mellow Mushroom Carmel, IN - The Story

Inspired by the local racing community as well as classic rock-and-roll legends, the restaurant features a large mural of a pink Cadillac with Elvis at the wheel. An old VW Bus has been outfitted with three large booths, so guests can enjoy their pizza in true 70’s style! At the entrance, guests walk under a floor-to-ceiling statue of a purple and blue mushroom to set the Mellow tone right at the door.

Generic Mellow Mushroom landing page kosmic karma gluten-free Generic Mellow Mushroom landing page hummus pita cocktail and carrots Generic Mellow Mushroom landing page beers drinks wings vegan cheese and pepperoni Generic Mellow Mushroom landing page burger and tots Generic Mellow Mushroom landing page the pacific rim pizza

About Mellow Mushroom Carmel, IN

Not far from the Indianapolis Motor Speedway, we’ve been a favorite of locals for more than 15 years. Our guests come in for the very best pizza, cold beer, a lively atmosphere, and a great time! We are proud to sponsor local school sports teams.

Feel free to bring your furry friend when you dine on our dog-friendly patio, we even have water bowls available for your pups! There is plenty of free parking in front of the restaurant. Come join us for weekly happy hour specials and try your new favorite pizza at Mellow Mushroom!

Can’t make it to the restaurant? Have your meal delivered right to your door! We offer great delivery and catering options, so you can keep it Mellow at any time.

Customer Reviews

One of the best pizzas I've ever had! From meat lovers to vegan they have all the pizza bases covered. As the name implies it's a very laid back place. The wall art is cool and the Greatful Dead playing in the background was an awesome touch. I will be back. This is a must see place, especially if your a hippy!

Took my parents here as my mom is a newly vegetarian and I knew they'd have us covered here and they did not disappoint! Food and service were great and the atmosphere and menus are just so cool from the tye dye menus to the murals on the walls. The decor is really fun! The pizzas we got were all great, and the calzone I liked, but unfortunately nobody else did.

First time at Mellow Mushroom and they have vegan cheese!!! I love dairy but dairy doesn't love me. Really good service/vibe and food.

Found this place. Just kind of lucky. I got an all meat calzone. My wife got a 5 topping pizza. It was all pretty. Darn. good. Never been there before but if we are ever back in that area we would not hesitate to eat there again.

Awesome experience and even better food! Had the cheesy bread and The merry prankster! Both were reasonably priced. Cheesy bread, pizza, and 1 drink with tip less than 40. Highly recommend.