Loading Light

Best Pizza Restaurant In
New Albany

Mellow Mushroom - New Albany

Mellow Mushroom has the best pizza in New Albany, Ohio. Our woodsy restaurant is located on Market Street. Mellow is a favorite for the locals in Columbus, Hampstead Village, Oyer Estates, and the surrounding areas.

Craving pizza? Maybe it’s time to try something a little more unique. We’re known for our homemade crust and stone-baked pizzas with bold combinations. And if we can make pizza special, just imagine what we can do with a munchie, salad, calzone, or even a burger. Are you hungry yet? Definitely. Take your pick from our selection of 50 draft beers and our tasty, handcrafted cocktails. And, many of our pizzas can be made gluten-free or vegan.

Store Information

Store information Mellow Mushroom New Albany signage
Monday - Thursday
Friday - Saturday
Happy Hour
Monday - Friday
4:00 - 7:00PM

260 Market St, Ste A, New Albany, OH, 43054

To-go orders
Pick up TO GO orders at the carryout counter
Social Media

Reserve a Room

Throwing a party for a crowd? Reserve a Private Room at Mellow Mushroom.
Private Dining Room: 45 Seated Guests or 65 Standing Guests
Room Fee: Friday and Saturday, $750 Minimum Food and Beverage Orders. Sunday - Thursday, no cost
Reservations: Click the button below to reserve or call 614-245-4234

Weekly Events

Monday - Friday
Happy Hour
4:00 - 7:00PM
Featured Cocktail, Domestic Beer, Wine, and Liquor Specials
Tap Takeover
Third Thursday of Every Month

Mellow Mushroom New Albany - The Story

Inspired by the outdoors, the interior of the restaurant is made mostly of reclaimed barn wood. The ceiling is lined with bridge-like structures. Custom paintings of cartooned forest scenery wrap the walls. A large tree draped with lights breaks through the ceiling. The wall behind the tree is covered in signs for streets and beers, and a stacked stone fireplace adds coziness next to the tree. Fittingly, the restroom entrance looks like an outhouse. The custom bar top is inspired by a stream and a canoe chandelier lights the bar area. For guests who prefer to dine outdoors, the patio offers regular and high-top tables and a fire pit.

Mellow Mushroom Sarasota landing page vegan cheese Sarasota pizza colored background spread Mellow Mushroom New Albany main dining high tables chairs Mellow Mushroom Hilton Head Carousel Image 4 Mellow Mushroom Sarasota landing page specialty cocktails Generic Mellow Mushroom landing page mellow bites Generic Mellow Mushroom landing page holy shiitake pizza Generic Mellow Mushroom landing page burger and tots Generic Mellow Mushroom landing page kosmic karma gluten-free

About Mellow Mushroom New Albany

Located near Rose Park, our restaurant has been a local favorite since 2015. Guests come in regularly for the very best pizza, cold beer, craft cocktails, a fun atmosphere, and a great time! We are proud to sponsor local schools and sports teams.

Bring your furry friend when you dine on our dog-friendly patio — and make sure you introduce us! Find parking around the building. Come join us for tap takeovers, bourbon tastings, and happy hour specials. Try your new favorite pizza at Mellow Mushroom!

Can’t make it into the restaurant? Have your meal delivered right to your door! We offer great delivery and catering options, so you can keep it Mellow any time.

We’d like to say to our guests: “Thank you for welcoming us to the community and making us a popular local hangout!”

Customer Reviews

Wow! We’re locals but this was our first time trying MM. Definitely won’t be our last. Let me start by saying our server, Daniel, was fantastic! Very personable & attentive. The Cloud 9 wings & Kosmic Karma pizza were AMAZING. Five stars. We’ll be back!

Friendly staff, fun atmosphere, and good food. Double baked garlic parmesan wings may be some of my favorite! Pizza was great too, fresh ingredients. Will be back again. Update: brownie is really good too Update 2: tried the double oven baked hot wings today, very good

The food here is amazing, and it's my favorite of the Mellow Mushroom locales in central Ohio for that reason. The staff is super friendly, accommodating, and attentive. The veganized holy shiitake is my regular order here. The others have liked the Thai Dye pizza and the buffalo chicken version. That being said, they always mess up one of our orders, and we often end up waiting a good 30+ minutes extra for one of our dishes. The servers and managers have always taken care of us when there has been a mixup in the kitchen, and they discount our order, so we keep coming back here despite the drive, but if you have plans afterwards, keep possible delays in mind.

Food was absolutely delightful. Oven fresh pizzas and piping hot wings. We had the mushroom pizza and house and they had their own unique delicious pallets. It did take a while for the food to come but it's worth it. We were nearly done eating and our waitress did not offer any more drinks or refills on our practically empty water and took quite a bit of time to get the check from us.